[ Ain't that the truth, though Karkat was way too polite to mention it while Terezi was with her. Besides, he's seen worse moirails. Eridan and Feferi, for example... ]

In that case, it sounds more likely that your Moirail actually has the emotional capacity to give you what you need than whatever-the-fuck Dave tried to pull off. My only concern is if they'll be satisfied with a pale relationship.